Finland's Supreme Court upholds ex-Jehovah's Witness's conviction for publishing elders' faces and voices

In a precedent given on 19 November 2026, the court held that a 2020 article criticising the Witnesses' shunning teaching dealt with a matter of public importance, but that showing two local elders unblurred and with unedited audio clearly exceeded what was acceptable. A district court had acquitted the author; the court of appeal convicted him.
Finland's Supreme Court has upheld the criminal conviction of a former Jehovah's Witness who published the faces and voices of two congregation elders in an online article criticising the religion's practice of shunning. The court gave its judgment on 19 November 2026.[1]
The published judgment replaces the names of everyone involved with letters. Finland's national broadcaster, Yle, has reported that the convicted man is Jari-Pekka Peltoniemi, and that the sentence left in force is 20 day-fines, a fine counted in daily units.[2]
The ruling, numbered KKO:2026:82, is a precedent: a decision the Supreme Court publishes as a guide for later cases. It deals with where Finnish criminal law draws the line between criticising a religious teaching and protecting the privacy of unpaid local congregation officials. The court held that the article addressed a matter of public importance, and that it could have done so without identifying the two men. Three courts heard the case and reached two different results.[1]
What was published
The charge covered 7 to 10 December 2020. Peltoniemi published an article on his website, which the judgment describes as critical of Jehovah's Witnesses, under a headline that reads in translation: "A lesson in spiritual violence was presented at the weekly meeting."[1]
Its subject was shunning (karttaminen in Finnish): the community's practices toward people who have left it or been expelled. The court summarised the teaching, as the article described it, as the rule that such a person should in principle be isolated from all members of the congregation, relatives included.[1]
Attached to the article were unblurred screenshots of two elders and unedited audio of presentations on shunning that they had given, from their own homes, at an online congregation meeting. The judgment calls the two men B and C.[1]
The meeting had been filmed with the elders' consent. It was streamed live and kept viewable for a week in a service open to anyone who had access rights or a freely shared invitation link. Peltoniemi obtained the recording through such a link.[1]
The unblurred version stayed online for about two weeks. Peltoniemi then blurred the faces and edited the audio so that the men could not be recognised.[1]
The elders and the congregation
The judgment describes elders as members who take part, without pay, in the teaching, guidance and leadership of their local congregation. Both men had also served for about 11 years as "pioneers", a role in which, the court noted, each did various kinds of voluntary work.[1]
Their congregation operated within a single city and had about 140 members at the time. Neither man was actively visible on social media or the internet, either as a private person or in his congregation role.[1]
Why Peltoniemi published
Peltoniemi was a Jehovah's Witness until 2006, Yle reported in January 2024. By his own account he was expelled because he refused to shun his sister, who had been expelled earlier. "Since my expulsion I have not seen a single Jehovah's Witness relative," he told Yle. "They all shun me one hundred percent."[3]
He told Yle he published the recordings to draw attention to what he sees as a gap between the Witnesses' public statements about shunning and what the community teaches.[3]
In the same report, Jehovah's Witnesses spokesman Jukka Palonen told Yle by email that the Witnesses encourage members to live by Bible principles, and cited the instruction in First Corinthians to "stop keeping company" with an expelled person. "Each individual member of the congregation decides, on the basis of their conscience and circumstances, whether to end contact or limit it in line with the instruction," he said.[3]
The charge and the two sides
The prosecutor charged Peltoniemi with two counts, one for each elder, of "dissemination of information violating personal privacy" under chapter 24, section 8 of Finland's Criminal Code. The offence is committed by someone who, without the right to do so, puts information, an insinuation or an image about another person's private life before a large number of people in a way likely to cause that person damage, suffering or contempt.[1]
The same section contains an exception. An expression made in order to deal with a matter of public importance is not an offence unless, given its content, the rights of others and the other circumstances, it "clearly exceeds what can be considered acceptable".[1]
Peltoniemi asked for the charge to be dismissed. The judgment records his arguments: the information did not concern the elders' private lives; they had spoken not as private individuals but as elders who exercise power in the congregation and had sought a public role within it; and they had taught, at a filmed public meeting, a doctrine that has drawn wide public attention.[1]
The two elders joined the prosecutor's demand for punishment.[1] According to Yle, each claimed 3,000 euros for suffering. They argued that their religious beliefs were highly sensitive private information, that they were private individuals and not wielders of power, and that the article insinuated they were guilty of spiritual violence.[4]
Three courts, two outcomes
Finland has three tiers of general courts: district courts, courts of appeal, and the Supreme Court.
The Länsi-Uusimaa District Court acquitted Peltoniemi on 8 December 2023. Judge Camilla Valtti found that publishing the images and audio was unlawful and likely to cause harm. But she held that it did not clearly exceed what was acceptable, given his aim of addressing a matter of public importance. She also found that the elders' beliefs were not private information, given their significant role in the congregation.[1]
The prosecutor and the elders appealed. On 31 October 2024 the Helsinki Court of Appeal convicted Peltoniemi on both counts and fined him. It held that the elders were private individuals in the eyes of the general public, and that revealing their identities was not necessary to discuss the subject.[1]
Yle reported that the court ordered him to pay each elder 750 euros plus legal costs. Peltoniemi told Yle he was disappointed and that elders must, by virtue of their position, tolerate public criticism. "They have a position of power in the congregation, which is used to maintain the shunning doctrine," he said.[4]
The Supreme Court then gave Peltoniemi permission to bring the case before it, known as leave to appeal.[1]
Local elders are not "wielders of power"
Finnish law, the Supreme Court explained, gives the narrowest privacy to people who wield power in society, and the widest to ordinary individuals. Public figures fall in between.[1]
The court held that the elders' role did not make them, from the general public's point of view, wielders of power with reduced privacy. They were "comparable to ordinary private individuals". Their faces and their religious beliefs were therefore private information protected by the Criminal Code.[1]
Consent to the stream did not change that. Peltoniemi had neither asked for nor received permission, and the court held it irrelevant that the elders had allowed their presentations to be filmed, streamed and kept available for a limited time in the religious community's own service.[1]
Being known as a believer inside a congregation, the court added, cannot be equated with having that fact made generally available on the internet.[1]
Public importance and the blurring question
The Supreme Court held that the article "clearly dealt with a matter of public importance". It pointed to the effects of the shunning teaching on the lives of people who are either socially isolated or required to isolate others, such as their relatives.[1]
That left one question: whether the way the article was published clearly went too far. The court held that it did.[1]
The two elders as individuals, the court said, had no bearing on the subject. By their own account, they had not written their presentations: the meeting's content was the same in every congregation and came from the Jehovah's Witnesses' head office in the United States. Peltoniemi himself said his criticism was aimed at the community's practices and teachings, not at the two men. The article's aims could therefore have been met without revealing anything about their private lives.[1]
Peltoniemi said he left the images and audio unaltered to underline that the material was authentic. The court held that this was not an acceptable reason for failing to blur the faces or take similar precautions.[1]
The court weighed two articles of the European Convention on Human Rights, a treaty binding on Finland: Article 8, which protects private life, and Article 10, which protects freedom of expression. It relied on rulings of the European Court of Human Rights, which interprets the treaty, including:[1]
- von Hannover v. Germany (no. 2) and Axel Springer AG v. Germany (2012), which set out the factors for balancing the two rights
- Egill Einarsson v. Iceland (2017), applying those factors to a private person's speech online
- Bremner v. Turkey (2015) and Hájovský v. Slovakia (2021), on publishing unblurred images of private individuals
- Haldimann and Others v. Switzerland (2015), which gave weight to the blurring of a face and the altering of a voice
Reach of the website
Evidence in the case showed that Peltoniemi's website reached no more than several hundred people a day. The court held that this, and the two-week period, did not settle the matter. Given search engines and the nature of the internet, it said, information once published can be almost impossible to remove, and the images could resurface at any time.[1]
Five justices decided the case: Tuomo Antila, Kirsti Uusitalo, Eva Tammi-Salminen, Tuija Turpeinen and Pekka Pulkkinen. The operative part of their judgment is a single sentence, in translation: "The outcome of the Court of Appeal's judgment is not changed."[1]
Sources
- PrimarySupreme Court of Finland (Korkein oikeus), precedent KKO:2026:82, given 19 November 2026 (ECLI:FI:KKO:2026:82; diary no. R2024/1017). Full Finnish text as published by the court, including its account of the Länsi-Uusimaa District Court judgment of 8 December 2023 (no. 23/150165) and the Helsinki Court of Appeal judgment of 31 October 2024 (no. 24/138142). Primary source, read in full. https://www.korkeinoikeus.fi/ennakkopaatokset/ennakkopaatokset-vuosittain/kko202682/
- NewsYle, "Korkein oikeus vahvisti entisen Jehovan todistajan tuomion – nettijulkaisu loukkasi seurakunnan vanhimpien yksityisyyttä" ("Supreme Court upheld former Jehovah's Witness's conviction: online publication violated congregation elders' privacy"), report on the Supreme Court judgment of 19 November 2026. https://yle.fi/a/74-20257978
- NewsYle MOT, "Entinen Jehovan todistaja julkaisi ääninauhoja osoittaakseen, mitä uskonyhteisön kokouksissa todella tapahtuu – oikeus hylkäsi syytteet" ("Former Jehovah's Witness published audio tapes to show what really happens at the faith community's meetings: court dismissed the charges"), January 2024. https://yle.fi/a/74-20066011
- NewsYle MOT, "Hovioikeus tuomitsi entisen Jehovan todistajan sakkoihin" ("Court of appeal fined former Jehovah's Witness"), report on the Helsinki Court of Appeal judgment of 31 October 2024. https://yle.fi/a/74-20122517
Corrections: If you believe any factual statement here is inaccurate, please contact us. JW Files publishes corrections at the top of the original article and maintains a public corrections log.
Editorial note: This is a neutral news summary. Historical context, where present, is grounded in the Watchtower's own publications, shown as primary-source page images. Any interpretation lives in the separately-labeled editorial.